At Whitefish, we believe fine cigars aren’t just backrooms and backyards — they’re for pairing with exquisite foods like fine spirits. Our state-of-the-art humidor houses some of the best labels in the world; including some labels you might have a hard time finding anywhere else in the state. In fact, we’ve been chosen as an exclusive purveyor of Davidoff Cigars’s most premium offerings.
Cigar List
Aging Room, Quattro F55 Concerto
Size: 7 X 50 (Churchill)
Strength: Medium/Full
Country: Dominican Republic
Cigar Aficionado Rating: 95
Tasting Notes: …”Balanced, sophisticated cigar that displays rich notes of roasted coffee bean and sweet cedar.” Cigar Aficionado
Alec Bradley, Prensado
Size: 5 X 50 (Robusto)
Strength: Full
Country: Honduras
Cigar Aficionado Rating: 92
Tasting Notes: “The Robusto hits the palate with a flavorful interplay of cocoa powder and vanilla balanced by cedar and hints of dried fruit, making for a tasty smoking experience.” Cigar Aficionado
Arturo Fuente, Rosado Sun Grown 44
Size: 4 7/8 X 47 (Robusto)
Strength: Medium/Full
Country: Dominican Republic
Cigar Aficionado Rating: 94
Tasting Notes: “We love the cigars, which have a savory leather core and a smattering of sweet spices on the palate.” Cigar Aficionado
Brick House, Mighty Mighty
Size: 6.5 X 60 (Corona Gorda)
Strength: Medium/Full
Country: Nicaragua
Cigar Aficionado Rating: 89
Tasting Notes: “A nice balance of spice, sweetness and strength” Atlantic Cigar Co.
Gurkha, Cellar Reserve Edicion Especial
Size: 6 X 58 (Grand Robusto)
Strength: Medium
Country: Dominican Republic
Cigar Aficionado Rating: Not Rated
Tasting Notes: “…well-balanced and complex smoke.” Atlantic Cigar Co.
Hoyo de Monterrey
Size: 6.75 X 48 (Double Corona)
Strength: Medium
Country: Honduras
Cigar Aficionado Rating: 88
Tasting Notes: “A medium-bodied smoke with some grassy notes.” Cigar Aficionado
My Father, Flor de las Antillas
Size: 6 X 52 (Corona Gorda)
Strength: Medium
Country: Nicaragua
Cigar Aficionado Rating: 96
Tasting Notes: “… with notes of nutmeg, white pepper and just enough strength without being overpowering.” Cigar Aficionado
Oliva, Serie V Melanio
Size: 6.5 X 52 (Figurado)
Strength: Full
Country: Nicaragua
Cigar Aficionado Rating: 96
Tasting Notes: ”…rich, big notes of leather framed by a range of coffee, caramel and woody intonations.” Cigar Aficionado
Padron, 1964 Aniversario Exclusivo Maduro
Size: 5.5 X 50 (Robusto)
Strength: Medium/Full
Country: Nicaragua
Cigar Aficionado Rating: 94
Tasting Notes: “Rich and heavy with roasted espresso and dark cocoa bean flavors that are complemented by notes of dried cherries and ripe apple. Flavorful and sophisticated.” Cigar Aficionado
Rocky Patel, 1999 Connecticut
Size: 6.5 X 52 (Corona Gorda)
Strength: Mild/Medium
Country: Honduras
Cigar Aficionado Rating: 88
Tasting Notes: “delivers a notably creamy, bready smoke with sweet touches of cinnamon and minerals.” Cigar Aficionado
Alec Bradley, Tempus Imperator
Size: 6 1/8 X 52 (Figurado)
Strength: Full
Country: Honduras
Cigar Aficionado Rating: 89
Tasting Notes: “There are some cedary, leathery snaps in the beginning of this meaty cigar, accompanied by mineral notes and a briny finish” Cigar Aficionado
Arturo Fuente, Hemingway Best Seller
Size: 4.5 X 43/55 (Perfecto)
Strength: Medium
Country: Dominican Republic
Cigar Aficionado Rating: 92
Tasting Notes: “This little cigar has a dark, oily wrapper. It is rich and peppery, with complex flavors and a long finish.” Cigar Aficionado
CAO, Cameroon
Size: 5.50 X 55
Strength: Mild/Medium
Country: Nicaragua
Cigar Aficionado Rating: None
Tasting Notes: “Mild to medium bodies in taste and box-pressed – an attractive, high-quality smoke” Atlantic Cigar Co.
Foyle, Epee
Size: 4.5 X 40 (Petit Corona)
Strength: Medium
Country: Honduras
Cigar Aficionado Rating: 87
Tasting Notes: “…boasting deep flavors of pepper, cedar, caramel, almond and cream. Handcrafted and cured with extensive cedar aging, these boutique stogies present a smooth and complex smoking experience.” Best Cigar Prices
Gurkha, Cellar Reserve Kraken
Size: 6 X 60 (Super Toro)
Strength: Medium/Full
Country: Dominican Republic
Cigar Aficionado Rating: Not Rated
Tasting Notes: “…the Cellar Reserve is a delicious medium to full-bodies cigar that is full of flavor and complexity.” Universal Cigars
La Aroma de Cuba Mi Amor
Size: 5.25 X 56 (Figurado)
Strength: Medium/Full
Country: Nicaragua
Cigar Aficionado Rating: 95
Tasting Notes: “…has a lovely woody component balanced by notes of sweet nougat and copious amounts of nuts on the palate. These cigars are not only delicious, but consistent.” Cigar Aficionado
Liga Privada, #9 Belicoso
Size: 6 X 52 (Figurado)
Strength: Full
Country: Nicaragua
Cigar Aficionado Rating: 91
Tasting Notes: “… lush, earthy, espresso-like flavors of the full-bodied Liga Privada cigar are an undeniable luxury to the seasoned smoker’s refined palate.” Jr Cigars
My Father, Le Bijou 1922
Size: 6 1/8 X 52 (Torpedo)
Strength: Medium/Full
Country: Nicaragua
Cigar Aficionado Rating: 93
Tasting Notes: “…a red-pepper spice that evolves and sweetens, taking on a distinct cocoa powder and coffee bean character, yet remains balanced.” Cigar Aficionado
Padron, Family Reserve 50 Years, Maduro
Size: 5 X 54
Strength: Medium/Full
Country: Nicaragua
Cigar Aficionado Rating: 94
Tasting Notes: “…it is steeped in notes of rich earth, coffee and that trademark cocoa bean quality.” Cigar Aficionado
Rocky Patel, Decade Cameroon
Size: 6.5 X 52 (Toro)
Strength: Medium/Full
Country: Honduras
Cigar Aficionado Rating: 87
Tasting Notes: “delivers sharp, cedary notes that mellow out to convey hints of dried berries, fresh tobacco and dry wood.” Cigar Aficionado
Rocky Patel Decade
Size: 5 X 50 (Robusto)
Strength: Medium/Full
Country: Honduras
Cigar Aficionado Rating: 93
Tasting Notes: “is profoundly woody and leathery complemented by spicy, chewy notes that lead to a sweet liqueur finish.” Cigar Aficionado
Arturo Fuente, Hemingway Signature
Size: 6 X 47 (Perfecto)
Strength: Medium
Country: Dominican Republic
Cigar Aficionado Rating: 92
Tasting Notes: “It’s full in body, smacking of creamy vanilla and cinnamon spice, with a leathery, peppery finish.” Cigar Aficionado
Ashton, VSG Spell Bound
Size: 7.5 X 54 (Churchill)
Strength: Medium/Full
Country: Dominican Republic
Cigar Aficionado Rating: 93
Tasting Notes: “… loads the palate with leathery, cedary smoke. Despite Ashton’s best efforts to increase production, the VSG line remains in short supply.” Cigar Aficionado
E.P. Carillo La Historia E-lll
Size: 6 7/8 X 54 (Churchill)
Strength: Medium/Full
Country: Dominican Republic
Cigar Aficionado Rating: 95
Tasting Notes: “… offers a rich balance of earth and coffee notes underscored by woodiness and a sweet touch of anise on the finish.” Cigar Aficionado
Foyle Maduro
Size: 5 X 50 (Robosto)
Strength: Medium
Country: Honduras
Cigar Aficionado Rating: Not Rated
Tasting Notes: “earthy expresso notes of flavor. What makes the wrapper on this stick impart such a silky smooth finish is it is fermented under intense heat for 90 days until it releases its full potential-a rich… and delights with an elegant, luxurious finish.” Superior Cigars
H. Upmann, 1844 Reserve
Size: 6 1/8 X 52 (Belicoso)
Strength: Medium/Full
Country: Dominican Reppublic
Cigar Aficionado Rating: 93
Tasting Notes: “… a smooth, medium-bodied smoke that’s rich in flavor and complete with notes of earth, nuts, pepper, and cedar.” Cigars International
La Gloria Serie R, Esteli, No. Fifty-Four
Size: 6 X 54 (Corona Gorda)
Strength: Full
Country: Nicaragua
Cigar Aficionado Rating: 91
Tasting Notes: ” the Serie R Esteli was made exclusively for brick-and-mortar cigar shops. It’s one of the best La Glorias in years, with a core of leather and coffee notes complemented by a nutty and floral character.” Cigar Aficionado
My Father, No. 3
Size: 6 X 49 (Corona Gorda)
Strength: Full
Country: Nicaragua
Cigar Aficionado Rating: 93
Tasting Notes: “a toasty smoke balanced by woody and orange peel flavors and a cocoa finish.” Cigar Aficionado
Oliva Serie O
Size: 7 X 50 (Churchill)
Strength: Medium/Full
Country: Nicaragua
Cigar Aficionado Rating: 94
Tasting Notes: “The smoke is delicious, with a salty, earthy flavor punctuated by tasty dried cherries and hints of cocoa and cedar” Cigar Aficionado
Padron, 1926 No.2 Maduro
Size: 5.5 X 52 (Robusto)
Strength: Full
Country: Nicaragua
Cigar Aficionado Rating: 93
Tasting Notes: “A rich, complex figurado that is full of caramel, coffee and nuts, with touches of licorice.” Cigar Aficionado
Punch, Gran Puro Santa Rita
Size: 4.5 X 52 (Robusto)
Strength: Medium/Full
Country: Honduras
Cigar Aficionado Rating: 91
Tasting Notes: “…delivering sweet and floral smoke with profound undertones of leather, dried red fruit and a hint of cinnamon.” Cigar Aficionado
Romeo by Romeo Y Julieta Toro en Tubo
Size: 6 X 54 (Corona Gorda)
Strength: Full
Country: Dominican Republic
Cigar Aficionado Rating: 92
Tasting Notes: “…dark, oily smoke has meaty notes, hints of dark roasted coffee and a complex character. “ Cigar Aficionado